The Power of Online Reviews: How They Impact Your Business, SEO, and Customer Choice

Online reviews have become a critical factor in how customers choose businesses. With 88% of consumers trusting online reviews as much as personal recommendations, your business's online reputation can make or break your success. Beyond influencing customer choice, reviews also play a significant role in your SEO, making them a key element of your digital marketing strategy.

How Online Reviews Impact Your Business

Online reviews are often the first impression potential customers have of your business. Positive reviews attract new customers, while negative ones drive them away. Reviews also build credibility, as consumers are more likely to trust the opinions of others who have already experienced your services. This trust is crucial, particularly for local businesses, where word-of-mouth and community reputation are vital.


The SEO Benefits of Online Reviews

Reviews impact customer perceptions and influence your website's search engine ranking. Google considers reviews when determining a business's credibility and relevance, particularly for local search results. The more positive reviews you have, your business will likely appear higher in search results, driving more traffic to your site.

According toSearch Engine Land, businesses actively seeking and responding to reviews can significantly improve their local SEO. Engaging with reviews shows search engines that your business is active and committed to customer satisfaction, which can further boost your rankings.


Good vs. Bad Review Responses: Do's and Don'ts

How you respond to positive and negative reviews can greatly influence customer perception. Here's a guide to handling reviews effectively:


Do's and Don'ts of Responding to Reviews

  • Do respond promptly to all reviews, showing that you value customer feedback.
  • Do thank customers for positive reviews and express appreciation for their business.
  • Do address negative reviews calmly and professionally, offering to resolve the issue offline if possible.
  • Do keep your responses brief and to the point while still being personal and sincere.
  • Don't ignore negative reviews or get defensive. Acknowledge the customer's experience and show a willingness to improve.
  • Don't use generic responses. Tailor your replies to each review to show that you're genuinely engaged.
  • Don't offer incentives for positive reviews, as this can come across as disingenuous and may violate review platform policies.

Tips and Tricks for Managing Online Reviews

  1. Encourage Reviews: Ask satisfied customers to leave reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, or Facebook. Make it easy by providing direct links in follow-up emails or on your website.
  2. Monitor Regularly: Monitor your reviews across all platforms and respond promptly to positive and negative feedback.
  3. Use Reviews for Improvement: Treat negative reviews as an opportunity to improve your services. Address the issues raised and make necessary changes to avoid similar complaints in the future.
  4. Share Positive Reviews: Highlight positive reviews on your website and social media to build credibility and attract new customers.
  5. Stay Professional: Always maintain a professional tone in your responses, even if the review is unfair or overly harsh. Your response is public, and potential customers will judge your business based on how you handle criticism.



Online reviews are a powerful tool for building trust, improving SEO, and influencing customer decisions. You can enhance your business's reputation and drive growth by managing your reviews effectively, responding thoughtfully, and using feedback to improve your services. Remember, how you handle reviews—good and bad—can make a lasting impression on potential customers and play a significant role in your business's success.

A green stamp that says myth busted on it
By Taralyn Carter April 29, 2025
If you’re a local business owner, you’ve probably heard it all when it comes to online marketing: “SEO is a scam,” “You don’t need a website if you’re on Facebook,” or “Google Ads are only for big companies.” Let’s clear the air.  At Flypaper, we work with hundreds of small to mid-sized businesses across the country—so we know what actually works and what’s just noise. Today, we’re debunking some of the biggest digital marketing myths and sharing what local businesses truly need to grow their online presence.
A person is holding a model house and keys in their hand.
By Taralyn Carter April 22, 2025
Two property management companies in Arkansas took unique approaches to digital marketing. One focused on maintaining a simple online presence, while the other utilized a comprehensive, data-driven strategy with a range of digital marketing services. 
A man is working on a roof next to a picture of a roof with a chimney.
By Taralyn Carter April 22, 2025
This case study compares two roofing companies—one leveraging multiple Flypaper services and another relying only on a website. The results highlight the impact of a full-scale marketing strategy.
A man is applying tint to a car window and a man is installing a windshield.
By Taralyn Carter April 16, 2025
Having an online presence is just the beginning. This case study compares two Arkansas-based auto glass companies—to illustrate the difference between using a full-suite digital marketing strategy and relying solely on website hosting.
By Taralyn Carter April 15, 2025
Two med spas took different approaches to their digital marketing. While one relied solely on online presence, the other invested in multiple Flypaper services. This case study explores how their strategies influenced growth, customer engagement, and overall performance.
A man is cutting a tree with a chainsaw and another man is working on a HVAC unit.
By Taralyn Carter April 15, 2025
Choosing the right digital marketing strategy is key to business growth. This case study compares a website-only client to one using multiple Flypaper services—showing the real impact of a full-scale approach.
More Posts